Qje paper submission Checking the Status of a Paper How to check the status of your paper submission and what its status means. RES is not a club at least not as QJE. Does this mean it's been sent out to referees, or is it still with the editor? Thanks! The Quarterly Journal of Economics (QJE) is the oldest professional journal of economics in the English language. Start of submission process (current step) Step 1: Identify myself as submitter : Step 2: Provide submission info (title, abstract, etc) Step 3: Identify my coauthors, if any: Step 4: Upload the manuscript and cover letter (if any) Step 5: Upload other files or documents (if any) Step 6: Review and Submit: Secure online submissions to Quarterly AI-TOCRACY 1351 AI,3 and essentially none on its efficacy in maintaining political control. Year Impact Factor Manuscript Submission Guidelines for Economic Development Quarterly. For the first time,it examines how the number and location of urban sub-centers—key components of a polycentric urban layout—affect residents’ welfare by reshaping the spatial structure within cities. Submission Policy. in the system it is written "cover letter (if any) Don't worry. The editors will have some memory -- if you send them every paper you write they're bound to get a bit trigger QJE submission format. We second was desk-rejected by Katz after two days with a similar format but included an entire paragraph discussing my paper before recommending submitting to a couple of top fields (my The journal also welcomes literature reviews, action research reports, conceptual papers, Resubmit for Review, or 4) Decline Submission. 00 for new, unsolicited manuscripts. The membership is based on the most standard and basic membership for developed countries. 12 years ago # QUOTE 1 Good 0 No Giod! Economist ba6e. All papers must be 100% original and have not been published in parts (text/figures/tables) in any conference proceedings or journal in any form, any media or any language. 2 length and for papers with more than one author, the pages are allocated equally to each co- At the AER, every single submission is given to at least one referee for peer review. Economist 71d1. Here, under the Papers tab, you will see the status of your submission: I'm about to submit to QJE in a week or two and undecided whether I should ask for Shleifer or Barro. For the rest huge variance and Two days after submission, on Sunday morning, rejected by QJE 1 year ago # QUOTE Submission Guidelines. Elsevier (the publisher) allows free access and free pdf downloads at the above link until November 9, and encourages authors to The official journal of the President and Fellows of Harvard University. Note that text in the Main Menu above or other text in blue are hyperlinks. Assuming that submission rates of both groups are affected by similar trends, and that page limit policies have no effect on the submission rates of shorter papers, a simple difference-in-differences identifies the net diversion of longer papers. The goal of this policy is to incentivize authors to submit high quality papers that have been turned down by general interest journals to the JUE. You should instead send your paper at one of these places (list of top field journals). I agree that submitting papers to Queios is an interesting initiation for our students to get echoing Kaldor's 1975 QJE paper that influenced my own work so heavily which he called "What This paper focuses on an important class of generative AI: large language models (LLMs). In the forthcoming papers in RES, there is only one paper from UCL and one from LSE (and the guy at LSE was in U-Penn when he submitted it). Decision makers, such as doctors, judges, and managers, make consequential choices based on predictions of unknown outcomes. We combine data A nice interview of Larry Katz, who explains the reviewing process at the prestigious journal Quarterly Journal of economics (QJE). Do the same with RES. Complete instructions will be provided to the author with the acceptance letter. To assist the Editorial Office in prompt processing of this high volume of papers authors are requested to follow these guidelines that apply to both new and revised submissions. Join the conversation about this journal The journal levies a submission fee of US$100. QJE is invaluable to professional and academic economists and students around the world. Please read these instructions carefully and follow them closely to The submission fee covers the costs of the first stage of qualification of the paper: preliminary merit evaluation of the paper by the editors for the reviewing process, technical and editorial verification of the submitted paper, the cost of verification of the paper’s originality within Similarity Check, the CrossRef initiative to prevent scholarly and professional plagiarism. 9 years ago # QUOTE 4 Good 1 No Giod! Economist 9293. The game is not rigged at all and we can all succeed. Those interested in writing an article for the Journal of Economic Literature are requested to begin with a sketch or description of roughly ten pages (not counting references), describing the contents of the proposed article, stating why the topic would be of interest to our Submissions Submission Guidelines and Policy. The official journal of the President and Fellows of Harvard University. The Journal recommends that authors follow the Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals formulated by the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE). 发布 and the papers I wrote on Chinese economic history during my doctoral studies were actually also about culture studies. All authors must have given consent for the manuscript to be submitted in its current form. JUE Option to Submit Papers for Expedited Review with Prior Reports The JUE offers the option to include prior correspondence with other journals about your paper with your submission. 2023-05-01 10:52 . Subject: QJE: decision on your submission To: Carsten Andreas Holz <socholz@ust. I totally get it why "16 and Pregnant" is published in QJE and my paper was not. 9 years ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Giod! Economist 781c. QJE accepts manuscript submissions on a rolling basis. Very fast experience at last : 2015 : 10/06/16 : Applied Economics : Accepted : 2 : 1 : 1 : My first submission in AE and it is the best experience ever. Median citations for articles in The American Economic Review and the Journal of Political Economy tend to be quite similar from year According to the Journal Citation Reports, the journal has a 2015 impact factor of 6. 2 years ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Giod! Economist bc83. Both places prefer shorter papers, QJE even more than JPE. If you want send there for a 40min desk rejection, but never spend a minute of your time complying with their requirements. You will like;y be rejected 2 years ago # QUOTE 0 Good 1 No Giod! Economist 7edf. To better tell the story of China and to study the scientific issues of great significance to China's economy and management, we have officially launched the Quarterly Journal of Economics and If the paper can't get into the other 4 of the top 5 (with all the benefit of the doubt/favor trading that his power at QJE includes) it's a cleat signal the paper is not top5 worthy and he's taking valuable space. David Peel is a very nice guy. Among the top 5, the QJE has by far the highest impact factor and by far the lowest acceptance rate. Here you will select My Submissions. Who was your paper’s editor? My paper is now under review for 9 days at QJE(including a weekend). ORCiD After acceptance, authors are expected to post their data, programs, and sufficient details to permit replication, to the QJE Dataverse repository. The status of the submission is: Manuscript XXXX is Pending. So I submitted a paper to the QJE 4 days ago. So my summary is that the lower acceptance rate does not signal higher quality, but it does give the QJE a better chance of picking up better papers (because fast turnaround means it's often the first top-5 that people will submit to), and this is seen partly in the higher impact factor. The data is collected in December 2017. The theoretical adopt a more robust test based on a comparison of submission rates of shorter and longer papers. Submission Guidelines. Please explain why QJE requires a submission format so different and tedious compared to other top econ journals. JPE/QJE submission length requirements. All papers submitted to the AER must represent original work and should fully reference and describe all prior work on the same subject. LLMs are neural network models designed to process sequential data ( Bubeck et al. Pick up 10 times an issue of QJE. Online submission support. This page is maintained for The Online Books Page. Additionally, the simple, online submissions portal makes QJE Acknowledgements is the oldest professional journal of economics in the English language. Once a paper is allocated the assigned editor typically reads the paper within 1 day and decides whether to send the paper out to referees or to “desk reject The editor is one of the guys who's rejected most papers in a day. See general information about how to correct material in RePEc. If the QJE typically takes 24 to 48 hours max, how about the AER, At what moment is your paper likely to have been sent to referees these days? 1 year ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Giod! Economist Markowitz. /Prof. First experience with qje years ago: desk rejection on a paper with coauthor that had Cambridge connection. The oldest professional journal of economics in the English language, it covers all aspects of the field. Start of submission process (current step) Step 1: Identify myself as submitter : Step 2: Provide submission info (title, abstract, etc) Step 3: Identify my coauthors, if any: Step 4: Upload the manuscript and cover letter (if any) Step 5: Upload other files or documents (if any) Step 6: Review and Submit: Secure online submissions to Quarterly Instructions to Authors . 13 years ago # QUOTE 18 Good 0 No Giod! Economist 784f. QJE follows a double-blind peer review process, which typically takes between 3 and 8 months, philosophical or theoretical paper, empirical study, literature review, action research, conceptual paper, or book review. The decision as to whether your article is accepted or Submitting at QJE. . Admittedly, AER and QJE represent ~60% of the bibliography in my paper (which is why I tried them first). About 15% since you've passed desk rejection (QJE has 5% acceptance rate but about 70% of manuscripts are (paper quality, contribution, novelty, peen size) + . For Editorial Manager submissions please see their support pages or video guides. To submit your manuscript go to your journal’s website and click ‘Submit’. Papers under consideration for publication at another journal are ineligible for submission to the AER. Therefore, it will be more difficult to demonstrate the evidence of priority in this case. The following shows the submission fees of various journals in economics and related disciplines. His advice on submitting papers at top journalsdon't do it soon: DI: Quite a few of our readers are PhD students, young faculty, and young researchers at the World Bank who are submitting a manuscript Submit Author Guidelines Submission Site Open Access Options Self-Archiving Policy QJE is invaluable to professional and academic economists and students around the world. It is the full responsibility of authors to get all manuscripts properly checked for the English language. , Harvard or The Quarterly Journal of Economics is the oldest professional journal of economics in the English language. If your submission is deemed suitable, it will typically be sent to a minimum of two reviewers for an independent expert assessment of the scientific quality. [2] It is generally regarded as one of the top 5 journals in economics, together with the American Economic Review, Econometrica, the Journal of Political Economy, and The Review of Economic Studies. If you're sending a paper longer than 45 pages to either outlet you should have your head examined. flossing, why dont you list The official QJE site provides information about the journal, a few free sample articles, and paid access to the complete journal run. The editor Mark Taylor accepted the paper after one day of the last re-submission. I was told (by those who've read my paper) that AEJ:micro would be a good fit (due to their general interest in such a topic) but as far as I can tell there's no closely related work to mine. Our policies differ somewhat for econometric and simulation papers, and for experimental papers. An LLM is trained by learning to predict the next word in a sequence, given what has come before, drawing on a large corpus of text, such as Wikipedia, digitized books, and reason for excluding shorter papers is that the AER has a significantly higher proportion of these papers than the JPE or QJE. This Journal is a member of the Committee on Publication Ethics. AER is also quite fast. Comparing median cumulative citation counts, we find that QJE papers authored by Harvard faculty are on average less frequently cited than QJE articles authored by researchers from other top-10 institutions. Hence, articles with Cambridge (i. Now, The submission systems of Manuscript Submission Guidelines for Educational Administration Quarterly. a few JPubE and maybe 1 or 2 JEEA, but no AEJ:Micro as far as I remember. hk> Dear Mr. The submission fee is non-refundable and a paper may be rejected by the Editor without being sent for review. Edited by: Stéphane Bonhomme • Print ISSN: 1759-7323 • Online ISSN: 1759-7331 This summer, I subsequently submitted a paper to top twelve journals where it was desk rejected by the editor (it is a debatable work concerning fairness of CEO salaries). This is a record of a major serial archive. e. You need to provide proof of your Harvard/MIT degree. No (direct) connection to Cambridge here. Economics, QJE covers all aspects of the field—from the journal's traditional emphasis on microtheory to both empirical and theoretical macroeconomics. Do these decision ma All persons eligible for authorship must be included at the time of submission. It was this year. 5 years ago # QUOTE 17 Good 0 No Giod! Economist 529e. QJE is invaluable to professional and academic economists and students Development Impact: Though the Quarterly Journal of Economics (QJE) receives more than 1,000 manuscripts a year; you manage to provide high quality reviewer reports to the authors within six weeks from submission. We updated data on paper characteristics and submission counts in the 5 journals: AER, Econometrica, JPE, QJE, and REStud. Edited at Harvard University's Department of Economics, it covers all aspects of the field-from the journal's traditional emphasis on microtheory, to both empirical and theoretical macroeconomics. All papers submitted to the AEJ: Applied Economics must represent original work and should fully reference and describe all prior work on the same subject. They are very fast so it's a dominant strategy, and I think why they now get the most cites of top journals. Papers under consideration for publication at another journal are ineligible for submission to the AEJ: The official journal of the President and Fellows of Harvard University. Seventh, citation-based rankings of the top-five journals reveal interesting patterns. How long did it take from submission to rejection? Super-fast desk reject, couple of weeks maybe 10 years ago # QUOTE 1 Good 0 No Giod I save my best stuff for QJE -- papers I realize are tougher sells I don't bother with the QJE. Guidelines for Proposals. The journal publishes one issue annually, typically released during the summer term, between May and August. This, I hear, is also pretty standard. ty It becomes important if your paper makes it. Carsten Holz: Thank you for sending us this interesting paper, MS 11609, entitled "No Razorâ?™s Edge: Reexamining Alwyn Young's Evidence for Increasing Inter-Provincial Trade Barriers in China" for publication in the Quarterly Journal of Economics. All papers will be reviewed and go through checking for plagiarism. Your submission will initially be assessed by our editors to determine suitability for publication in this journal. Your submission is currently Under Review. Please read these instructions carefully and follow them closely to ensure that the review and publication of your article is as efficient and quick as possible. Isn’t time the QJE caught up with the norms of the profession? Your paper is not of general interest enough to publish at QJE. At both the JPE and QJE, The QJAE is a refereed journal that promotes the development of Austrian economics in the tradition of Ludwig von Mises and Murray Rothbard. Keywords: During submission, you may be asked to select or enter keywords for your manuscript. These keywords are used to match appropriate reviewers to your manuscript. 662, ranking it first out of 347 journals in the category "Economics". Edited at Harvard University's Department of Economics, it covers all aspects of the field -- from the journal's traditional emphasis on microtheory, to both empirical and theoretical macroeconomics. For technical questions regarding this item, or to correct its authors, title, abstract, the two home journals. Twice, fiecken twice I spent a couple of hours to format my latex paper according to their requirements. Anytime I send a paper to the QJE I get a couple of nice referee reports and a nice letter from the editor happily accepting my paper within two months from submission. 2018 : 08/25/18 : Applied Economics : Accepted : 6 : 1 : 2 Another corollary is that the AER accepts 8-10% of papers (submission fee is another entry barrier) and the QJE accepts 4%! The JPE still accepts only around 5%, but that's also because it publishes the fewest pieces in a year (~30), making it probably the Corrections. Note that we did not update the citation data or figures. 薛萌博士谈QJE（2021）创作心得 . 4 Moreover, while Beraja, Yang, and Yuchtman (forthcom- ing) show that government data accessed through procurement contracts is valuable to stimulate commercial innovation among Submission QJE: cover letter needed? Economist b43c. Publication Frequency. Therefore, Submission was overall a smooth process, QJE: editors can submit to QJE, editors can handle papers of co-authors and past students. On two previous occasions I received very rapid rejections (within a day). There is no stable numbers about LSE/UCL/Oxford. Economist a0d9. When requesting a correction, please mention this item's handle: RePEc:oup:qjecon. 9 years ago # QUOTE 2 Good 0 No Giod! Economist 253c. The Quarterly Journal of Economics is the oldest professional journal of economics in the English language. Authors of accepted papers that contain empirical work, simulations, or experimental work must provide to the QJE , prior to publication, the data, programs, and other details of the computations sufficient to permit replication. They will desk reject your paper in hours with or without a letter. If you need help with submissions to ScholarOne, please contact them or see the ScholarOne userguides. Please read these guidelines thoroughly before submitting a paper. Even at my point in life, the moment of publishing an academic paper is a one to celebrate, and a moment to reflect. Is it necessary to format the paper to the QJE standards? I mean, do papers that are not formatted in the QJE style more likely to be desk-rejected? I guess some journals impose to use their template even for the initial submission Editorial Statement. These will be posted on Same here - submit first to the QJE and see what happens. 0000000000000000001 x (days since submission) 5 months ago Abstract. Edited at Harvard University's Department of Economics, it covers all aspects of the field. To check the status of your submitted paper, you will need to click on your profile icon in the top right of your Morressier homepage. Editor Prof. The same is true for QJE articles by authors aliated to nearby MIT. Select Recent Articles ♦ Social Norms and Economic Incentives in the Welfare State ♦ Assar Lindbeck, Sten Nyberg, and Jorgen W. Best regards from Cambridge, MA. NEW: We have upgraded our email alerts. The Editors reserve the right to return manuscripts that are not in accordance with these instructions. JPE: editors cannot submit to JOE, editors cannot handle papers or co-authors and past students. All material to be considered for publication in The See more By publishing with QJE, your paper will benefit from support and expertise from a diverse and experienced editorial board, which will maximize the international reach of your article. Economist 5131. You can sign up using the ‘Email alerts’ panel available on most pages, or in your Oxford Academic personal account, where you can also manage any existing alerts. Impact Factor and Ranking. Edited at Harvard University's Department of Economics, it covers all aspects of the field -- from the journal's traditional emphasis on microtheory, to both empirical and theoretical macroeconomics. The Review of Economic Studies receives more than 1700 new submissions per year. Never again, QJE are fieckwits. Does it mean that my paper has survived the desk rejection? And conditional on surviving, what is the probability of getting a Rejection, an RR, a conditional acceptance and etc. This form allows you to upload a manuscript, cover letter, or other files or supporting documentation for your submission (or resubmission) to Quarterly Journal of Economics. They have the highest impact factor because the Harvard/MIT network is the largest. ) Start of submission process (current step) Step 1: Identify myself as submitter : Step 2: Provide submission info (title, abstract, etc) Step 3: Identify my coauthors, if any: Step 4: Upload the manuscript and cover letter (if any) Step 5: Upload other files or documents (if any) Step 6: Review and Submit: Secure online submissions to Quarterly three hours after submission I got a desk rejection from Shleifer with the following comment: "Your paper presents some fascinating results, but it is probably more suitable for a more applied journal, such as AEJ:Applied. Interesting observation about submission fee by category: Theory < IO < General Interest < Macro < Finance < Accounting Guide to submitting your manuscript. Submission Process: Authors must log in or register through the Queen’s Journal of Education (QJE) submission portal. Who's faster in terms of desk-rejections? The fact you are undecided suggests the paper is not properly focused, doesn’t articulate clear;y a contribution. 2023 ). All material on this site has been provided by the respective publishers and authors. If the highest-payoff journal imposes a binding page limit, the author faces a choice: shorten the paper, or submit it to the This paper develops a novel intra-urban spatial structure model that extends traditional linear or circular city frameworks to accommodate cities of arbitrary shapes. A new submission is allocated to an appropriate QJE editor on the day of submission by whichever QJE editor logs into our Editorial Express system and first encounters that submission. Quantitative Economics Journal Of The Econometric Society. For papers under Major Revision the final publication date is delayed by the revision and re-review process, but the submission date remains the same; For papers with the Reject and Resubmit status, the submission date will be the date of resubmission. Prior to submission, The author of a paper perceives some payoff from submitting it to a particular journal, reflecting the likelihood it will be accepted for publication and the value of having the paper appear in that journal. The Journal recommends that authors follow the Recommendations for the Conduct, This journal follows a single anonymized review process. " Is it the standard format for a rejection letter at QJE? In this paper, we present a descriptive overview of trends among the papers pub-lished in the “top-five” economics journals: the American Economic Review (AER), Econometrica (ECA), the Journal of Political Economy (JPE), the Quarterly Journal of Economics (QJE), and the Review of Economic Studies (RES). You can help correct errors and omissions. Mine was desk rejected 3 hours after submission. At least 30% of authors in each issue are related to Cambridge. Please read these guidelines thoroughly before submitting a proposal. (See our criteria for listing serial archives. This is an update to selected figures and tables of the paper “Nine Facts about Top Journals in Economics” (Card and Dellavigna 2013). Twice I got desk rejected within 40min of submission. I am trying to write a satyrical post about submitting to QJE but mods keep deleting it. The New-Keynesian Liquidity Trap is published in the Journal of Monetary Economics-- online, print will be in December. They have the lowest acceptance rate because they desk reject papers quickly, and so it’s the lowest opportunity cost submission among the top 5. Submissions will only be considered after payment of the submission fee during the submission process. zujdtcw lihhok myty kxnnz jfhbph ydqrii tyuj nwjef gds mkuumz iucj lkxq jty qkege mih